Behavioral Finance 2.0 - Financial Psychology (2024)

Journal of Financial Planning:May 2017

Bradley T. Klontz, Psy.D., CFP®, is a co-founder of the Financial Psychology Institute™, an associate professor of practice at Creighton University Heider College of Business, a managing principal at Your Mental Wealth Advisors™, and an author/editor of several books.

Edward J. Horwitz, Ph.D., CFP®, ChFC®, FBS, CLU®, CSA, is the Mutual of Omaha Endowed Executive Director in Risk Management, and an associate professor of practice at Creighton University Heider College of Business.

The financial planning profession has a growing interest in blending psychology theory and techniques with financial planning. The most recent edition of CFP Board’s Financial Planning Competency Handbook illustrates this integration with new chapters on financial therapy, behavioral finance, and marriage and family therapy applications to financial planning. The Journal has also recognized the benefits of this trend, as evidenced by the 2016 Montgomery-Warschauer Award given to Sarah Asebedo and Martin Seay for their psychology and financial planning integration article “From Functioning to Flourishing: Applying Positive Psychology to Financial Planning” published in the November 2015 issue.

Where We’ve Been

Early efforts to integrate psychology with finance focused on behavioral finance. Behavioral finance is built on the premise that human beings don’t always act in their best financial interests. Practicing financial planners, who frequently witness clients act against their own interests, intuitively understand this.

Whether it’s buying high and selling low, holding on to poor investments to avoid feelings of regret, selling a winning investment to experience feelings of pride, or refusing to diversify a concentrated position, poor investment decisions are ubiquitous. The field of behavioral finance has identified a host of cognitive biases explaining and predicting these types of behaviors. This includes constructs such as status quo bias, mental accounting, overconfidence, the disposition effect, and others.

Behavioral finance has historically been broadly defined as the application of psychology to finance. However, a closer look at the behavioral finance research reveals what is more accurately described as the application of a particular field of psychology to finance. In essence, behavioral finance is the application of cognitive psychology to finance (see the 2016 book Facilitating Financial Health: Tools for Financial Planners, Coaches, and Therapists by Bradley T. Klontz, Rick Kahler, and Ted Klontz for more).

The American Psychological Association defines cognitive psychology as “the study of higher mental processes such as attention, language use, memory, perception, problem solving, and thinking.” In its application of cognitive psychology to finance, behavioral finance has provided valuable information regarding common cognitive biases and thinking errors and how they impact financial decisions.

Where We Are

Our knowledge about behavioral finance has grown from laboratory research and analyzing large datasets. The bulk of behavioral finance research has been conducted by economists and finance professors—not financial planning practitioners. The studies are typically designed, conducted, and analyzed by researchers who have limited—if any—direct experience working with clients. This has led to a significant disconnect between research and practice, which is a common schism in many fields. While behavioral finance concepts can be quite fascinating, aside from a basic understanding of natural human tendencies, most planners are at a loss regarding how to apply this information to help their clients.

Consider a hallmark of behavioral finance research findings on the disposition effect first identified in 1985 by economists and finance professors Hersh Shefrin and Meir Statman in the Journal of Finance article, “The Disposition to Sell Winners Too Early and Ride Losers Too Long: Theory and Evidence.” Based on an analysis of aggregate stock and mutual fund trades over a several-year period, they observed that in an effort to seek pride and avoid regret, investors had a tendency to sell shares that had appreciated in value and hold onto shares that had lost value. These behaviors run counter to what would be expected if individuals were acting in their best financial interests.

This observation by Shefrin and Statman helps explain the cognitive underpinnings of a self-destructive financial tendency. However, where such behavioral finance research provides tremendous value in understanding human behavior and motivation, it fails to offer strategies to intervene on a client’s cognitive biases. In many cases, this type of research is conducted by theoreticians and statisticians who have never sat in front of a client, nor tried to shape a client’s behavior. As such, application discussions are often an afterthought.

Current Limitations

Behavioral finance research begs questions such as: “How do I convince my client to sell a losing position when her pride won’t let her admit defeat?” “What should I do when my client is exhibiting a bias towards the status quo?” “How should I tactfully address my client’s overconfidence in his prediction of future market directions?” Aside from macro-finance interventions, such as automatic 401(k) enrollment, behavioral finance provides little theory or few techniques to help shape the financial beliefs and behaviors of individuals, couples, or families.

Another limitation of much of the current behavioral finance literature is that it focuses on the findings of cognitive psychology. Behavioral finance just scratches the surface of what psychology has to offer the planning profession, potentially ignoring other fields of psychology, many of which may be more useful to practicing financial planners. These include social psychology, personality psychology, multicultural psychology, positive psychology, family psychology, and developmental psychology. The broader integration of psychology into the world of personal finance has been termed “financial psychology” by Klontz, Kahler, and Klontz.

Financial Psychology

Financial psychology can be seen as akin to clinical psychology, which “integrates science, theory, and practice to understand, predict, and alleviate maladjustment, disability, and discomfort as well as promote human adaptation, adjustment, and personality development,” according to the American Psychological Association. Applied clinical psychology draws from the entire body of psychological theory and research to apply findings to alleviate maladjustment and promote adaptation in individuals and groups.

Similarly, financial psychology draws from behavioral finance and other areas of psychology to help alleviate financial stress and promote healthy financial behaviors. Financial psychology focuses on using psychological research and theory to create micro-based techniques to help shape idiosyncratic financial beliefs and behaviors to improve financial health. These efforts go beyond cognitive biases into the realm of a client’s idiosyncratic beliefs, such as money scripts and financial behaviors like resisting financial advice, overspending, financial enabling, and financial anxiety.

Making It Relevant

To make behavioral finance more relevant to planners, an expansion into more practice-oriented fields of psychology is needed. For example, how does a client’s upbringing impact their financial beliefs and behaviors? Once problems are identified, how can a planner help a client? Techniques adapted from schools of psychotherapy can be helpful, such as cognitive-behavioral therapy, motivational interviewing, solution-focused therapy, or positive psychology. These areas of psychology are perhaps most useful for financial planners who want to help clients identify, challenge, and change cognitive biases.

To be useful to financial planners, the findings of behavioral finance need to be viewed from the broader context of financial psychology. Behavioral finance has identified our common, in-born cognitive biases, which when left unhindered, can have a detrimental impact on our financial outcomes. It’s also important to take into account a client’s unique personality, developmental history, social, cultural and gender influences, and family dynamics, and how these have shaped their idiosyncratic beliefs and behaviors.

With our broadening understanding of client psychology, the financial planning field continues to benefit from practice-oriented solutions to equip planners to better understand, assess, intervene, and shape clients’ financial beliefs and behaviors to improve their financial health and overall well-being.

I'm Bradley T. Klontz, Psy.D., CFP®, a co-founder of the Financial Psychology Institute™ and an associate professor of practice at Creighton University Heider College of Business. I'm also a managing principal at Your Mental Wealth Advisors™ and an author/editor of several books, including "Facilitating Financial Health: Tools for Financial Planners, Coaches, and Therapists" (2016) co-authored with Rick Kahler and Ted Klontz. My co-author and expert in the field is Edward J. Horwitz, Ph.D., CFP®, ChFC®, FBS, CLU®, CSA, who holds the Mutual of Omaha Endowed Executive Director in Risk Management position at Creighton University Heider College of Business.

In the May 2017 edition of the Journal of Financial Planning, we delve into the growing interest in blending psychology theory and techniques with financial planning. This integration is highlighted in the CFP Board’s Financial Planning Competency Handbook, which introduces new chapters on financial therapy, behavioral finance, and marriage and family therapy applications to financial planning.

Our expertise stems from extensive involvement in the financial psychology domain. I have co-authored a book that provides tools for financial planners, coaches, and therapists, demonstrating a practical application of psychological insights to financial issues. Moreover, my co-author, Edward J. Horwitz, brings a wealth of experience as the Mutual of Omaha Endowed Executive Director in Risk Management and an associate professor of practice.

The article discusses the historical evolution of integrating psychology with finance, initially focusing on behavioral finance. Behavioral finance, rooted in cognitive psychology, examines how cognitive biases impact financial decisions. However, it is noted that the disconnect between research and practice exists, with much of the behavioral finance research conducted by economists and finance professors who lack direct experience working with clients.

The limitations of current behavioral finance literature are outlined, emphasizing the need for more practical interventions. Questions are raised about convincing clients to make rational financial decisions and addressing biases effectively. The article introduces the concept of "financial psychology" as a broader integration of psychology into personal finance. Financial psychology draws from various fields, including social psychology, personality psychology, multicultural psychology, positive psychology, family psychology, and developmental psychology.

The relevance of financial psychology is emphasized, particularly in understanding how a client's upbringing, personality, and cultural influences impact their financial beliefs and behaviors. The article suggests incorporating techniques from psychotherapy, such as cognitive-behavioral therapy, motivational interviewing, solution-focused therapy, and positive psychology, to help clients identify, challenge, and change cognitive biases.

In conclusion, the article advocates for a broader understanding of client psychology within the financial planning field. By integrating findings from behavioral finance into the broader context of financial psychology, planners can better understand and address clients' idiosyncratic beliefs and behaviors, ultimately improving their financial health and overall well-being.

Behavioral Finance 2.0 - Financial Psychology (2024)

References

Top Articles
Technical Assistant, Theatre based, Depuy Synthes, Durban/KZN
Sales Consultant [Mitek Sports Medicine - Detroit, MI] - DePuy Synthes at Johnson & Johnson | The Muse
Buhl Park Summer Concert Series 2023 Schedule
Oklahoma Dam Generation Schedule
Buff Streams .Io
Shining Time Station (television series)
Cpt 90677 Reimbursem*nt 2023
Lox Club Gift Code
An Honest Review of Accor Live Limitless (ALL) Loyalty Program
Browse | Obituaries | Enid News and Eagle
University Of Michigan Paging System
Yellow Kitchen Curtains Walmart
Amy Riley Electric Video
Best Internists In Ft-Lauderdale
Ticket To Paradise Showtimes Near Movie Tavern Bedford
Learning Channel Senior Living
Papa's Games Unblocked Games
The Blind Showtimes Near Showcase Cinemas Springdale
Uitstekende taxi, matige gezinsauto: test Toyota Camry Hybrid – Autointernationaal.nl
Sweeterthanolives
Dollar Tree Hours Saturday
Fox News Live Stream USA HD - USNewsON
Sdn Upstate 2023
Po Box 24410 Omaha Nebraska
NFL Week 1 games today: schedule, channels, live streams for September 8 | Digital Trends
Peloton Guide Stuck Installing Update
Generac Find My Manual
Susan Dey Today: A Look At The Iconic Actress And Her Legacy
Jersey Mikes Ebt
Hondros Student Portal
Frigjam
Switchback Travel | Best Camping Chairs of 2024
Aspect of the Dragons
Need flooring installation? Carpet Hardwood floor Vinyl plank Laminate - skilled trade services - craigslist
Fisher-Cheney Funeral Home Obituaries
101 Riddles for Adults That Will Test Your Smarts
Directions To Truist Bank Near Me
Hobby Lobby Locations Near Me
If You Love FX’s 'Shogun,' Here Are 10 More Samurai Things To Check Out
General Kearny Inn Motel & Event Center
1984 Argo JM16 GTP for sale by owner - Holland, MI - craigslist
Craigslist Nj Apartments South Jersey
Erica Mena Net Worth Forbes
Madrigal Pharmaceuticals, Inc. (MDGL) Stock Forum & Discussion - Yahoo Finance
Ups Carrier Locations Near Me
Basis Phoenix Primary Calendar
Craigslist High Springs Fl
Blood Types: What to Know
Conan Exiles Rhino Guide - Conan Fanatics
Chirp One Medical Seniors
866-360-2863
Latest Posts
Article information

Author: Jerrold Considine

Last Updated:

Views: 6152

Rating: 4.8 / 5 (78 voted)

Reviews: 85% of readers found this page helpful

Author information

Name: Jerrold Considine

Birthday: 1993-11-03

Address: Suite 447 3463 Marybelle Circles, New Marlin, AL 20765

Phone: +5816749283868

Job: Sales Executive

Hobby: Air sports, Sand art, Electronics, LARPing, Baseball, Book restoration, Puzzles

Introduction: My name is Jerrold Considine, I am a combative, cheerful, encouraging, happy, enthusiastic, funny, kind person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.